Definition of Document Review
Not many legal matters consist of only one document. In any litigation proceeding, you might have emails, contracts, spreadsheets, court filings, text messages, reports, and other electronically stored information. In the case of a merger or acquisition, there may be hundreds or thousands of contracts and documents to review. If it’s an internal investigation, reviewing emails and business documents may be required.
The issue is not simply locating such documents.
The real task is to find out which documents matter, what they consist of, whether they are relevant and privileged, and what steps should be taken with them further.
This is where document review comes in.
Document review refers to the process of systematically reviewing and categorizing documents in order to find information relevant to a legal matter, investigation, transaction or regulation. In eDiscovery, document review typically means the assessment of , responsiveness, privilege, and confidentiality of documents prior to their production.
This guide will give you a definition of document review, describe the process of document review, and explain its types, challenges, and best practices.
What is Document Review?
Document review is an analysis of documents aimed at finding information related to a particular matter.
In legal matters, document review involves emails, contracts, reports, spreadsheets, presentations, PDFs, messages, and other electronically stored information (ESI).
The specific purpose varies depending on the matter.
For instance, during litigation, lawyers may use document review to find out whether:
- A document is related to a legal issue
- It is responsive to a discovery request
- It is privileged information
- Information is confidential and needs protection
- It should be disclosed or withheld
- There is any fact in the document that can influence the legal matter
Document review is not limited to litigation; it can be conducted during mergers and acquisitions, internal investigations, regulatory issues, and due diligence.
The idea is not to just review all the documents. The idea is to make sense of a huge amount of data and turn it into useful legal information.
Why is Document Review Important?
A legal matter can generate massive amounts of information. Manual review without any workflow could be costly and time-consuming.
In addition, mistakes might pose risks.
Missing a pertinent document could have an impact on the matter strategy. Misclassifying a privileged document could raise disclosure issues. Consistent mistakes during review could also increase the difficulty of defending the process.
A well-conducted document review would help legal teams:
1. Determine relevant information
Reviewers are able to distinguish documents pertinent to the legal issue from other documents that are irrelevant to the matter.
2. Protect privileged information
Review would help legal teams identify communication between the client and attorneys prior to the production of any materials.
3. Cut down unnecessary review
Filters, deduplication, and technological processes would help in reducing the number of documents for human review.
4. Implement legal strategy
Identified relevant documents could include timelines, communications, connections, factual patterns, and other useful information that would influence how the matter should be handled.
5. Maintain consistency
A consistent review protocol would provide reviewers with consistent guidelines and coding standards.
Legal Document Review Process
There can be variations in workflows depending on the specific matter under review, but a legal document review process will typically entail several steps.
1. Defining the Scope of the Review
The first step before any review of documents takes place is defining the purpose of the review.
This could entail defining:
- The legal issues in question
- Custodians
- Date ranges
- Data sources
- Document review categories
- Criteria for relevance
- Criteria for privilege
- Confidentiality requirements
- Document production requirements
Having a good protocol for the review ensures that the document reviewers do not make assumptions regarding the relevancy or privilege of a particular document.
2. Collecting the Documents
Once the scope of the review has been defined, the next step entails the identification and collection of the documents.
This might include:
- Emails
- Attachments
- Contracts
- PDFs
- Spreadsheets
- Presentations
- Word documents
- Chats
- Internal documents
- Cloud-based data
- Mobile data
- Other types of electronically stored information
Today’s discovery workflow processes handle increasing amounts of data from various sources.
3. Process and Organize the Data
Raw data cannot usually be forwarded for review.
It must first be processed and organized.
This includes, among other tasks:
- Text and metadata extraction
- Conversion of files into searchable form (OCR)
- Elimination of duplicate data
- Identification of document families
- Data filtering
- Organizing the documents for review
In effect, one aims to create a reviewable collection of data.
4. Document Review for Responsiveness
This stage involves reviewing documents according to established criteria.
A reviewer will check if a document is:
- Responsiveness – Is it related or responsive to a specific discovery request or information need?
- Not relevant – Is it outside the scope of the search?
These results could be tagged accordingly.
5. Analysis for Privilege and Confidentiality
Relevance alone is not all there is to consider in the review.
There might be a need to assess the documents for any possible privileged or confidential information contained in them.
The reason for this is that a document might be relevant to the matter, but also contains an exchange that might fall under legal privilege.
Privilege review needs to be handled carefully. A review process needs to set out clear criteria on how privileged information would be identified and who would validate such decisions.
6. Analyzing the Reviewed Documents
After categorization of the documents, the next step would be analysis of the information.
Through analysis, we can identify such things as:
- Key individuals
- Key communications
- Chronologies
- Themes
- Events
- Document relationships
- Possible evidence
- Information gaps
7. Perform Quality Control
QC must never be seen as an optional process at the end of review.
Effective review processes are characterized by QC being done during the entire process.
This involves:
- QC through sampling of reviewed documents
- QC of reviewer reliability
- Coding decision QC
- Targeted QC
- QC of privilege decisions
- Statistical QC
- Revising review instructions if common problems arise
In short, quality review is achieved through QC processes including random and targeted QC as well as pre-production validation.
8. Plan for Production or Further Action
This stage will depend on the reason behind the review.
In litigation, the documents marked as responsive and not protected by any privilege will now be ready for production.
When there is an internal investigation, the deliverable may take the form of a structured report.
For due diligence, the deliverables will be risk summaries, contract abstraction, or an issue list.
What matters most is that document review will have actionable outputs, not just a finished coding spreadsheet.
What are the Various Types of Document Review?
Document reviews can differ based on the reason for conducting them.
1. Legal and eDiscovery Document Review
This is one of the more popular applications of document reviews at scale.
Legal teams review electronic documents to determine relevance, assess privilege and confidentiality, and produce the right documents.
In legal matters involving huge numbers of documents in the thousands or even millions, technology-based processes are particularly useful.
2. Due Diligence Document Review
Due diligence reviews are most often done in relation to business deals like mergers and acquisitions.
Legal teams may review:
- Commercial agreements
- Employment agreements
- Intellectual property records
- Legal history of the company
- Regulatory documents
- Corporate records
- Financial records
The goal is to determine anything that could affect the deal.
3. Internal Investigations Review
Document reviews are conducted by organizations when investigating any internal issue like allegations of misconduct, fraud, non-compliance, etc.
They may analyze emails, communications, reports, or any other documents to help them set up a timeline of events and gather evidence.
4. Regulatory and Compliance Review
Document review is also done by organizations to check whether any particular law or regulation is being complied with or not.
It depends a lot on the industry, jurisdiction, and regulatory landscape.
Manual v/s Technology-Assisted Document Review[KC1.1]
Manual document review is highly dependent upon the work done by lawyers or any other trained reviewer who reviews the documents manually.
For a smaller case, this might make sense.
However, for larger data sets, it becomes quite time-consuming and costly as well.
Technology-Assisted Review (TAR) uses technology, which includes machine learning and various other technologies, to help review the documents. According to Consilio, TAR and Continuous Active Learning were used to prioritize and organize materials for lawyer review and quality control.
Moreover, modern systems could even utilize AI for purposes like:
- Document Classification
- Identification of relevance
- Identification of privilege
- Summarizing
- Metadata Extraction
- Identification of concepts
- Analysis of similarities
- Prioritization of review
However, this does not mean that AI would always be considered a substitute for legal judgment.
The efficiency of AI-assisted review will depend upon the matter, the process involved in reviewing, the criteria being applied, and validation of output from the technology.
The pragmatic approach is becoming more of a “Human + Technology” approach. The use of technology by legal teams could assist in sorting and analyzing vast amounts of data.
The interpretation of such data would require the expertise of the legal professional.
Seven Best Practices for Legal Document Review
1. Establish Clear Review Protocol
Scope of review, criteria for review, categories to code documents, and escalation process need to be determined before document review.
This will give the same ground rules to all reviewers.
2. Reviewer Training before Conducting Document Review
Each reviewer should know the subject matter, the process of document review, the process of categorization, and the documents in grey areas.
Training is especially necessary in the case of multiple reviewers for one subject matter.
3. Apply the Right Use of Technology
Technology can be used to reduce duplication and prioritize documents.
It should not be done “for the sake of technology” or just because it is there.
4. Incorporate Quality Control into the Process
Do not find out about the problem with inconsistencies at the end of the process.
Incorporate ongoing sampling, validation, and feedback into the process.
5. Measure Review Metrics
Metrics that might prove helpful include:
- Reviewed documents
- Left-to-review documents
- Review rate
- Response rate
- Privilege rate
- Quality control error rate
- Consistency of reviewers
- Progress of the review compared to deadlines
Review metrics and daily reporting may help legal teams detect problems in time before the review is completed.
6. Ensure Information Protection
Document reviews usually involve sensitive and confidential information. Thus, access control and proper use of permission levels and technologies should be considered during the planning process.
7. Provide an Audit Trail
A defensible review must enable you to know:
- What was reviewed
- By whom it was reviewed
- What criteria were used
- Which technologies were used
- How quality control was done
This becomes especially important when the review is complex or is expected to come under scrutiny.
Some of the typical issues during the document review process include:
1. Large document volume
The volume of information that is electronically stored can easily overwhelm the human reviewers.
2. Inconsistent reviewer decisions
Without proper training, the reviewers might have different interpretations of the same instruction.
3. Risk of privilege identification mistake
The mistakes in privilege identification can cause serious complications.
4. Deadline pressure
The deadlines in litigation, transactional, and investigation cases mean that the team is required to review a large volume of data within a limited time frame.
5. Multiple data sources
The data could be scattered in emails, cloud storage, collaborative platforms, mobile phones, Teams and other applications.
What Should You Consider when Selecting Document Review Services?
In assessing the capabilities of a legal document review services provider, you should move past mere numbers–the number of documents that a service provider is able to analyze.
Consider:
1. Legal knowledge
Does the team know enough about the subject matter and legal aspects involved?
2. Review process
Is the process mapped out in terms of relevance, privilege, confidentiality and quality?
3. Technological capabilities
Does the service provider utilize eDiscovery technologies, analytics or artificial intelligence?
4. Quality control
Are the decisions of reviewers verified?
5. Security
Are the legal data and processes handled confidentially and securely?
6. Scalability
Can the review team cope with the task if the size of the matter increases?
7. Reporting
Are there reporting facilities provided to ensure visibility?
8. Defensibility
Can the service provider prove the defensibility of the methodology and its decisions?
While the provider should be able to show you how fast it can analyze the documents, it should also be capable of providing answers to the above questions.
Legal Document Review Checklist
Before starting a document review, consider the following questions:
- Why conduct the document review?
- Which documents/data sources are within the scope of the review?
- Which time period is applicable?
- Which custodians are applicable?
- What defines a responsive document?
- What privilege qualifications are in place?
- What confidentiality requirements exist?
- What coding classifications are necessary?
- What technology will be utilized?
- How will reviewers be trained?
- What measures for quality control will be taken?
- How will the process be measured?
- How will sensitive information be secured?
- How will decisions be made?
A checklist such as this may assist legal departments in preparing a consistent structure for conducting the review of documents prior to opening a document.
Conclusion
Document review is more than just speeding through documents. It is about understanding what is important, being consistent, securing confidential information, and ensuring a stable basis for decision-making by legal teams.
In view of the increasing number of documents, the proper blend of legal expertise, document review process, technology, and quality management will have a definite impact on the efficiency of a case.
This is where JurisIQ comes into play.
Using technology-driven legal services and striving for accuracy, consistency, and efficient document review processes, JurisIQ provides assistance to legal teams in dealing with document-intensive cases in a way that does not neglect the crucial thing, which is the legal knowledge behind each document.
Would you like some assistance in managing your document review case?
Contact JurisIQ today.
FAQs
What is document review in legal terms?
Document review in law refers to the examination of documents and electronically stored information to identify and examine documents and information that is pertinent to the legal case.
What are the various types of document reviews?
There are various types of reviews, including litigation and eDiscovery document review, due diligence review, internal investigation document review, compliance document review.
How does AI help in document review?
The uses of AI in document review include document classification, document prioritization, document summarization, pattern identification, and potential privilege identification. Its results should be tested within the context of the specific issue.
Is document review and eDiscovery the same?
No. Document review is one of the processes involved in the eDiscovery process. Other processes include identification, preservation, collection, processing, analysis, and production of electronically stored information.
What is Managed Document Review?
Managed Document Review is an outsourced document review process that allows a specific vendor to manage the entire or part of the document review process in terms of review personnel, project management, technology, and quality control.